CarMax offer comparison

Bring us your CarMax offer. Let a local buyer compete.

Bring the current written offer and the vehicle. A participating local franchise-dealer buyer will complete its own review and independently decide whether to issue a written offer for your car.

Start my local appraisal Review CarMax’s current process

Already have a number? Give us a look.A different buyer may reach a different offer.

A higher local offer is possible, not guaranteed. Compare complete current writing for the same vehicle.

What CarMax currently says

Start with the published process, then read your exact offer.

CarMax currently describes online and in-store offers that are subject to verification and valid for a stated period. Read the exact offer because vehicle condition, use, history, and handoff terms matter.

Official source reviewed September 2, 2026

Process at a glance

Two buyers can see the same car differently.

Inventory needs, resale plans, reconditioning assumptions, and local demand can differ. This is not a claim that either buyer will always be higher.

Compare	CarMax	Get More local review
Starting point	Online or in-store offer process	Online appraisal request followed by a selected local review—not an instant online value or offer
Verification	Vehicle information and condition verified under the written offer terms	Vehicle and required ownership information reviewed by a local franchise-dealer buyer before any offer is issued
Offer style	CarMax says its current offers are firm during the stated window	A participating local buyer independently decides whether to issue a written offer
Decision	Redeem or decline the CarMax offer	Compare written terms before choosing whether to proceed

Bring the complete offer

Five questions prevent a false comparison.

A screenshot of the headline number may leave out the details that change the net amount, timing, or handoff.

Compare offers completed within the same time window
Confirm both reviewers used the same mileage, condition, history, and equipment facts
Check how each buyer handles the lender payoff and remaining equity
Review payment type, appointment, transportation, and expiration details

Straight answers

Before you bring the offer.

Can I bring a CarMax offer to my Get More appraisal?

Yes. Bring the complete current written offer and give a participating local buyer the chance to review the same car. Compare any written offer it issues, including the amount, verification requirements, expiration, and handoff terms.

Will the local offer be negotiable?

Offer decisions and terms belong to the participating buyer. Ask the coordinator to explain the written amount and any conditions before deciding.

One more buyer

Your first offer does not have to be the only one you consider.

Give a local franchise-dealer buyer the chance to compete before you decide.

Start my local appraisal